Text Size: Zoom In

Jesus and Tolerance

Someone has said, “Wise are those who look at others with the same generosity they offer themselves, and, at themselves, with the same critical eye they have for others.”

Such advice is difficult to disagree with because it amounts to treating others the way we’d want to be treated. But just because the “golden rule” is hard to deny doesn’t make it easy to do. For instance,

How can followers of Christ practice generosity of spirit in a culture that has a reputation for tolerating everything but intolerance?

Let’s start by testing the question. Does our generation really tolerate everything but intolerance?

Daily news reports make it clear that our society is not as tolerant as its reputation. We don’t look the other way when executives get caught “cooking the books” of their company, or when politicians get nabbed taking money under the table, or when athletes test out positive for steroids.

None of us is tolerant when someone is breaking into our home, stealing our money, or hurting our children.

So why are some of us concerned that tolerance has become disproportionately important to our generation?

One reason is that democratic freedoms have allowed for the growth of religious, spiritual, and moral diversity. Over time, world views have multiplied with a resulting loss of moral and political consensus. In a society that defends freedom of religious expression, some choices involve privacy issues that are increasingly difficult to legislate and enforce.

How can the history of the Bible help us keep our perspective?

In many ways, the social and political conditions of our culture parallel the days of the New Testament. The pluralism of western society is similar to the multiculturalism of the Roman Empire.

Until the emergence of Constantine in the 4th century, the Caesars were not partial to Christ. On the contrary, the Roman Empire was marked by religious diversity and sexual license.

The New Testament, therefore, amounts to a series of case studies that show us how to live in conditions of diversity. In just such an environment, Jesus and his first followers show us how to have good judgment without being self-righteously judgmental in the process.

Because of our own limited perspective, Jesus gave us reason to think twice before judging others when he said,

(1) Judge not, that you be not judged.” (Matt 7:1-2).

(2) Condemn not, and you will not be condemned” (Luke 6:37).

Years later, a follower of Jesus by the name of Paul added his own reasons for not trying to play god with other people’s lives. He wrote,

(1) When the Lord comes, he will bring our deepest secrets to light and will reveal our private motives. (1Corinthians 4:5 NLT).

(2) Who are you to judge another’s servant?… Or why do you show contempt for your brother? For we shall all stand before the judgment seat of Christ (Romans 14: 4,10).

But as we’ve already suggested, such hesitance to judge others could not mean that followers of Christ need to claim ignorance when it comes to our need for moral discernment.

Jesus shows us how to have good judgment without being judgmental.

According to The Gospel of John, Jesus was full of both grace and truth (John 1:14). By combining both, Jesus gives us a model of moral insight and judgment while insisting that he, himself, was not ready to condemn anyone (John 3:17).

Consider for instance what happened when a group of religious men brought to Jesus a woman who they said had been caught in the act of adultery.

In an effort to pit Jesus against Moses they said, “Teacher… this woman was caught in the very act of adultery. The law of Moses says to stone her. What do you say?”

Jesus, acting as if he didn’t hear, stooped down and with his finger wrote something on the ground. When they insisted on a response, he stood up again and said, “All right, stone her. But let those who have never sinned throw the first stones! Then he stooped down and wrote again in the dust” (John 8:4-8).

John’s gospel goes on to say that when the accusers heard Jesus response, “They slipped away one by one, beginning with the oldest, until only Jesus was left in the middle of the crowd with the woman.

Then Jesus stood up again and said to her, “Where are your accusers? Didn’t even one of them condemn you?” “No, Lord,” she said. And Jesus said, “Neither do I. Go and sin no more” (John 8:8-11).

In that brief conversation Jesus showed good judgment without being judgmental. With masterful truth and grace, he gave the men, and the woman, what they needed to hear for their own good.

Those who were self-righteous and judgmental were graciously and truthfully reminded of their own sin. The one caught in adultery heard words of correction rather than condemnation.

In the process,

Jesus showed a desire to rescue before assuming his final role as our judge.

When, at the end of this age, the time does come for Jesus to judge the world (John 5:27-29), he will do so in a way that he alone is qualified to do:

(1) He will be a judge who walked in our shoes without sin.

(2) He will be a judge who suffered in our place to earn the right to be our Savior.

(3) He will be a judge who will weigh our acceptance or rejection of his salvation… and our acceptance or rejection of his offer to live his life through us…with perfect understanding.

Never has there been a better reason than Jesus– to want to live with good judgment, without acting like anyone’s final judge or jury.

Father in heaven, some of our most thoughtless acts have been to condemn those for whom your son died. Forgive us for presuming to judge others in ways that belong to you alone. Please give us the good judgment that we need to love others, as you have loved us.


Vote on whether you think this post is something you'll be thinking about:
Vote This Post DownVote This Post Up (+26 rating, 27 votes)
Loading...
18 Comments »

18 Responses to “Jesus and Tolerance”

  1. rokdude5 says:

    Funny, when I read this, Im thinking about those who live abroad or even here but are from a different culture but this applies to those whom we live with. How many of us choose to be non-judgmental when it comes to those we see as political adversaries or even our own troublesome neighbors down the street?

    Its hard to leave the judging to our Lord but we must. The only one we can judge is ourselves yet we can and should pray for those we wish to judge to hear and see the Light and be new followers of our Lord just like what He commanded us to do. Matt 28:19-20

  2. rokdude5 says:

    Mart, thanks for this blog. Its one of the things I love to wake up to every morning. Even though Im NOT a trained credentialed theologian, I got a feeling a good number of the bloggers are. I feel like Im getting a little peek into whats on the other side of the pearly gates.

    You may want to consider some sort of mechanism where fellow bloggers can communicate to one another if they so choose to do so. Of course there is an inherent liability there but I think the webmaster can figure out a safeguard or two.

    If I get out of hand with my dry humor, I apologize for my antics. Again, Thanks. Your bro in Christ..Rok

  3. chfranke says:

    Mart,
    A couple three comments:
    You reference Mat. 18:17 “If he refuses to listen to them, tell it to the church; and if he refuses to listen even to the church, treat him as you would a pagan or a tax collector.” This seems to beg the question of “How do you treat a pagan or tax collector?” Did Christ mean that there are certain people you are to treat differently than others?

    Regarding your reference to 1Cor 5:19-23: That doesn’t exist. You probably meant just 1Cor 5. That whole chapter seemes to apply. If that’s the case then I again point out that the last sentence (“11But now I am writing you that you must not associate with anyone who calls himself a brother but is sexually immoral or greedy, an idolater or a slanderer, a drunkard or a swindler. With such a man do not even eat.”) begs the question of “How do you tell which of your brothers is sexually immoral, a drunkard or a swiindler. (I left out idolater & slanderer because they are more obvious to tell.)
    In this section of your essay you indicate that these scriptures tell us how make wise choices. I’m not sure these two references make your point clear.
    Just a thought.
    Chuck

  4. GRANT says:

    Jesus’s FORGIVENESS is almost unique to Christianity, said Gary Inrig, in the Discovery Series entitled WHAT IS TRUE FORGIVENESS? It cited that Judaisn has little to say about forgiveness. I note that other religions do, like Budhism and Taoism. After reading it, I got the book THE SUNFLOWER out of the library. Forgivng the unforgivable is important for healing over time for all human beings. The Amish in Lancaster County, PA, forgave a shooter and his family for his rampage in an old Amish children’ school house, killing about six (?) kids. “Forgive us our trespasses, AS WE FORGIVE THOSE WHO TRESPASS AGAINST US” (KJV). The point made by Inrig was that even years after the Holocaust, at least one newly Christian survivor forgave a participant in that absolute human tragedy– forgiving the unforgivable does not mean forgetting!

  5. sitsathisfeet says:

    This is a very weighty subject. But if we turn the phrase to include discernment. Perhaps it will help. The Lord I believe wants us to have wisdom to discern how we should think,and act in a Pluralistic society. So rather than a judgement based view, we have a discerning view. Phil 1:10 And this is my prayer that your love may abound more and more in knowledge and depth of insight so that you may discern what is best… and James 1:5 If any of you lacks wisdom, he should ask God… and then there is 1 John 2:15 Do not love the world or anything in the world except we are called to love our neighbor as ourselves..Mark 12:31. So the question is are judgement and discernment mutually exclusive? No, but our judgements should always be tempered by how God wants us to act on those with discernment and Love. I find this one of the most challenging areas, (and know I can not do it on my own, but only God in me through the Holy Spirit can enable these things)Jesus said By myself I can do nothing, I judge only as I hear, and my judgement is just, for I seek not to please myself, but him who sent me. John 5 :30 If Jesus said that he the Man-God could do nothing by himself, so we can not judge rightly by ourselves we have to look to the Lord, sending everything through our faith filters of the Word to think, act and respond in discernment to judging. And pray to God that we can do it!

  6. poohpity says:

    Oh my Gosh Mart! That is totally what it is all about! Can you imagine what our church would look like if we truly followed Christs example. Maybe I am wrong but as an example he shed His clothes and wrapped a towel around His waist and washed the disciples feet. The greatest commandment was to love the Lord with all our heart, soul and mind. The second to love others as ourselves. He also said many times in the OT “I do not want your sacrifices I want you to know me and show mercy”. The great commission to go into all the world and tell them about HIM. We really have just got to get out of the way and let His love shine. He is the greatest judge because He knows our hearts and what they contain.

    I really want to be able to live what I have read in the Bible because the acceptance and love the Lord gives me and all others needs to be repeated. AMEN!

  7. BruceC says:

    Judge the sin. But leave the judgement of the sinner to God. You really know how to pick out the tough issues and throw them at us Mart! As a retired cop I had to judge others quite often. By that I mean according to law. To determine if a crime had been committed and if there was proof enough that a certain suspect committed said crime. Then it may go to trial where a jury would judge him guilty or innocent. Then a judge would take all things into consideration in passing out sentence. I may “tolerate” homosexuality in the sense that it exists and that some practice it and would come under judgement of God. I do not hate them for it as we are supposed to love and forgive others. However I do not tolerate their agenda being forced on society so that others have to accept that lifestyle as okay. As in love the sinner; hate the sin. In church would we tolerate gang members that practice lawlessness and violence? No. If there are absolutely no signs of repentence then someone openly practicing sin is a shame and blemish upon the church and hurts the credibility of the Gospel. I hope that I am not sounding confusing. “Judgement is a very tough topic in the church. What is your viewpoint Mart?

  8. Mart De Haan says:

    BruceC,
    Thanks for your perspectives. Wish we could all just sit around a big table and talk about this :-). Certainly law enforcement (Romans 13) as well as loving “church correction” of those who are living in blatant sin while claiming to be brothers and sisters in Christ is necessary (Galatians 6:1; 1 Corinthians 5).

  9. Valkiria says:

    Rokdude, welcome to my world! :) I love to come here, read and drop my 2 cents, even though I’m not “trained credentialed theologian” like you said!

    I have a hard time with this subject, as I was called out as “too judgmental” when I was adolescent, and I’m afraid to say, I still am ‘very judgmental’! Maybe because I saw so many things going wrong with my family (my father, my brothers and my sister ), that I have a real hard time accepting things that I consider bad. For instance, my brother was arrested once when he was younger, robbing a car. Last year, someone stole his car, when he told me, I said, “Well, now you know how the people you robbed felt!” I was criticized for that, and I ask God to forgive me, but I’m not one to accept certain things lightly! :(
    Val

  10. Gale L. Jarvis says:

    Good Morning everyone, Mart, I believe the Lord has given me several things i can now do because i have been given the power because i have been Born Again to do, if i believe these thoughts from him and desire to do them, the big word ( IF ) is usually mankinds down fall.
    The Holy Spirit has shwon me one way to stop being judgemental of another person in an evil way as far as their life stayle, or some terrible thing they are in the process of doing, or hearing some terrible thing a person has done through gossip from another person, or the many other ways we tend to judge others.
    the thought the Holy Spirit has given me comes from the mind and the lips of Jesus in one of his last thoughts forgive them THEY DO NOT KNOW WHAT THEY ARE DOING.
    As human being we do not have the ability to believe a person does not know what they are doing when we see them doing something we absolutely know they know what they are doing, but we have been given the power to believe God and my desire is to believe Jesus when he told me to forgive those that were taking his life, and has asked me to forgive others as he has fogiven me, no matter what they may be doing to me or someone else.
    Forgiving is not condoning what is being done, but i believe God desires for me to have compassion on the person that is doing me harm, or doing some terrible thing in my opinion, because God has given me the power to believe they do not know what they are doing.
    Another thing i believe that many will not except, but once again it is helping me in my life to get away from being critical of other and letting God be the Judge, and that thought is that every thing in life is a matter of opinion, even what i say i believe about God, thereby when i do not agree with what i hear another person saying, or see what they are doing and i do not agree, my desire is to not get angered, but my desire is to agree to disagree in love, knowing that my opinion of the matter is just mine, it satisfies me, there is no reason to judge the other person wrong and build up a barrier between our friendship if there is a friendship involved.
    Through my 75 years in this life i have seen so many friendships torn apart by just a disagreement over a thought, or posession of a very small material thing after a death in the family because of a judgemental disagreement.
    I do not have the thoughts you gave us a few days ago Mart, but they were sound things we need to stop and consider whether there is a need to stand up for what we are discussing or not, and in my opinion there are very, very few things in life worth loosing fellowship with another person over, and desiring to judge another person will cause us health problems, especially mentally. ( In my opinion )

  11. Mart De Haan says:

    Chuck and others, thanks so much for your feedback, I’ll be trying to correct and clarify the post over the next couple of days.

  12. daisymarygoldr says:

    Mart, it is a great article! but do you seriously mean to say that this post is going to stay here for the entire weekend? Ah-h-h I am terribly bored already and on my knees crying out to the “only judge”- how long do I have to “tolerate” and what have I done to reap this undeserved judgment? BTW, this is really unhealthy tolerance…or maybe it is healthy after all!

  13. Mart De Haan says:

    daisymarygoldr,
    :-). I’m struggling with applying this one too. Will see if I can change the subject. Need a little time though. Thought we were going to be out of town for the weekend. But weather changed. Rained all day. And we stayed put.

  14. daisymarygoldr says:

    How could a just God judge people who were without life and dead in their sins, who did not know the truth, who did not know the right way? Therefore, God revealed Himself to the world in Jesus Christ- who is the way, the truth and the Life.

    Jesus came to this earth to be judged (John 9:39) so that as the spirit reveals we the blind will be able to see the truth to either accept or reject Him. Those who accept have already passed from condemnation into eternal life; those who reject will be reserved for everlasting judgment.

    If we judge it is by human standards (John 8:15) which is different by God’s standard of Judging. Hence, as sinners, we do not judge and as frail people who always tend to falter, we cannot condemn the fallen. However, we cannot tolerate evil and should not fail to point people to Jesus and His Words- “See, you are well again. Stop sinning or something worse may happen to you.” (John 5:14)

  15. edwerd says:

    This article makes me wonder whether there are any spiritual overtones related to people individually and corporately having very little tolerance for others being able to have any directional and handedness variety and freedoms – such variety and freedom is continuously considered something nobody wants or would enjoy (sadly this is often true – I do not know if the lack of choices in handedness has caused apathy or apathy has caused a lack of choices but probably both are involved). Does the scripture give any insight about how God views forced handedness?

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.