Text Size: Zoom In

That Question I Couldn't Answer

I mentioned in my last post that, according to an online encyclopedia, only 15 percent of the Singapore population is Christian. I’ve since learned that those numbers are based on a 2000 census that some here in Singapore believe underestimates the number of practicing Christians. The problem is that the census assumes that if a head of household practices Taoism, or Buddhism, or Islam, the whole family therefore can be assumed to be of the same faith.

The fact is that, beginning in the 1950s and 60s a strong Christian youth movement resulted in many young people turning to Christ and, as they have aged and matured spiritually, they have produced a strong Christian presence in Singapore–even if their actual number is unknown.

Regardless, followers of Christ are a minority in a land that is heavily influenced by traditional Chinese ancestral worship, several other eastern religions, and the kind of global materialism reflected in this Singapore mall. The result is that many Christians here have struggled with a very difficult question that, over time, has troubled and even traumatized many of us.

Sometime ago, I tried to confront this question in an open letter to the many who have asked a question that seems too difficult at times to even think about. See whether you think it reflects what you know of the Bible and its Christ, even as we try to do everything we can to point others to the One who has died for us.

Dear Al,

The last time we talked, you asked a question I couldn’t answer. I remember the concern in your eyes and how helpless I felt to give you any assurance when you asked, “Does the Bible offer any comfort when we’re afraid someone we love has died without Christ?”

Your heartbreak is understandable. So is your anger. I can see why you feel that your faith has turned against you. Beliefs that once gave you comfort are now robbing you of sleep.

Other questions you asked have also been hounding me. Why didn’t our Lord help us with such an important issue? Why did the apostle Paul write as if his readers are concerned only about loved ones who “die in the Lord”? (1 Thessalonians 4:15-17). Didn’t he realize the impact his words would have on those who, because of their faith, would agonize even more deeply because they would have no hope of ever again seeing someone they love so much?

Your questions caught me off guard. But the longer I have thought about them, the more convinced I’ve become that even in our concern for unsaved loved ones we do not grieve as those “who have no hope.”

There is a time to comfort

As there is a time to warn, so there is a time to console. That comfort goes beyond our Lord’s assurance that He will someday wipe all tears from our eyes (Revelation 21:4). We can also find consolation knowing that it is none other than Jesus who will judge all of the earth (John 5:26-27). Because of the concern He showed for people during His life on earth, we can be sure He cares more about our lost loved ones than we do.

We see a hint of that compassion when Jesus mourned the unbelief of those who rejected Him (Matthew 23:37). We hear Him teaching His disciples to love their enemies (Luke 6:35). And in the moment of His deepest suffering, we hear Him say of those who called for His death, “Father, forgive them, for they do not know what they are doing” (Luke 23:34).

Ever since coming to know Christ, those of us who believe in Him have been learning to rely on Him more than on ourselves. We’ve been discovering that we can trust His goodness more than our own fears.

While believing that everything Jesus said about heaven and hell is true, we can cling to the truth that both mercy and justice have their origin in Him. The God whom Christ personified is not cruel. He will not add unnecessary pain to the fate of those who die rejecting Him. The suffering of judgment will be neither more nor less than it needs to be.

What we don’t know

We don’t know how our Lord will give “many stripes” (lashes of judgment) to some and “few stripes” to others (Luke 12:47-48), except that the punishment of some will be as severe as the punishment of others will be light. We don’t know the full meaning of the fire and darkness of judgment, except that the Hebrew prophet Isaiah first used the language of everlasting fire and smoke as a way of describing a battlefield defeat that is final and irreversible (Isaiah 34:9-10; 66:24).

What we do know

What we do know is that God will be fair, and good, and right in judgment. We know that not all will experience the same degree of pain and regret. All will be judged according to their works, which is one reason my grandfather Dr. M. R. De Haan said repeatedly, “To some, hell will be a little heaven compared to what it will be for others.”

The Scriptures show that those who suffer the severest judgment will be the devil, the Antichrist, the False Prophet, and those who accept the mark of the beast in the last days (Revelation 14:11; 20:10). In a similar way, Jesus reserved His strongest warnings for those religious leaders who used their influence to turn the crowds against Him.

There is a time to grieve

The apostle Paul grieved for lost loved ones without losing his mind or faith. He cared so much for Jewish family members that he would have taken their place in judgment if he could have. He said, “I have great sorrow and continual grief in my heart. For I could wish that I myself were accursed from Christ for my brethren, my countrymen according to the flesh” (Romans 9:2-3). Yet Paul’s concern for others didn’t rob him of his affection for heaven or his confidence in Christ (Philippians 1:23-24).

There is a time to rest

We cannot afford to let fear of what we don’t know about the future rob us of what we do know about our Savior and Lord. There is no better person to trust with the souls of our lost loved ones. He alone is their judge. He alone understands all of the factors that make faith and character more difficult for some than for others.

Most of our fears for those who have died lie not in what Jesus said, but in what we add by our own imagination. This is where we need to doubt ourselves and trust that even as He judges our lost loved ones the Lord will give us reason to worship and love Him forever.

Al, with you in mind, I bow my knees and pray, “Father, in heaven, at the end of our own fears, and at the end of our own wits, we cast ourselves upon You. We take comfort in the fact that You take no joy in the death of lost people. We cling to the assurance that You, our Father, the Judge of all the earth, will do right.”


Vote on whether you think this post is something you'll be thinking about:
Vote This Post DownVote This Post Up (+51 rating, 51 votes)
Loading...
13 Comments »

13 Responses to “That Question I Couldn't Answer”

  1. Lynda Lim says:

    I too was once troubled by the death of loved ones who died not knowing the Lord. But I have since learned to trust in God’s judgement. As Mart said, God takes no joy in the death of lost people. It is His desire that all be saved. We only can do our part in sharing the gospel and praying that they be saved. Ponder on those things that we do know, shun those we do not understand when it confused us. God bless.

  2. paul bishop says:

    Mart: The question is, if there is another chance
    for those who have died. I ask you, does scripture
    support a second chance in judgment, such as the
    Book of Life. Do we,as believers, escape the judgment
    seat of Christ? These and other issues demand more
    attention than mere eternal qualifications. I am
    more convinced of the truth represented by the Bible
    than speculation. There must be black and white
    answers that are consistent with scripture.

  3. pegramsdell says:

    Wow! Well said. Thank you Mart for this answer to a very hard question. This helps in so many ways. For myself and I’m sure for others I come in contact with. After all, God is just and fair. And His mercy endures forever. And He is very patient and longsuffering.

  4. BruceC says:

    So to speak; been there done that. A good brother in the Lord brought comfort to me over this very same question. He asked “Do you trust the Lord?”. I answered yes, and He said to trust Him with this then.
    I pray and hurt in my heart for those in my family and in my wife’s family that don’t know Christ. But I shall continue to pray and not give up.
    Good topic Mart. Many believers struggle with this. With the joy of Christ in their heart it truly is difficult to understand why anyone would not want to know Him.

  5. drkennyg says:

    Just this week I went to a viewing and then a funeral for a very good friend who died suddenly at 60 of a heart attack. He was never sick for most of his life. We never talked much about our beliefs but I know he …did not attend any church. I was quite saddened because I had obviously missed an opportunity to witness to him. Although he was a bit of a “free spirit” as he liked to say, I was fearful for his salvation and whether he is in heaven now or not.

    I know that he gave much of himself to others with little regard for his own safety when he saw that someone needed his help. One instance involved him stopping his car when a women on the sidewalk struck him as not looking quite right. He walked back to her asking if she was OK. Turns out she had been raped and he took her to the hospital – she was extremely grateful for his help. The hospital personnel and police wanted to know who he was for being a witness although he really saw nothing until after the fact. He often did random acts of kindness like that without any fanfare for himself.

    His daughter told me at the funeral that he had accepted Jesus as his Savior much earlier before I knew him. He was always quiet about matters of faith and did not really like talking about it. Anyhow I was greatly relieved to know of his Christianity and am now more certain that he is in heaven. Yet I can only hope and never really know while I’m here on the earth.

    Our God is a perfect and just God and is certainly worthy of our praise and adoration in view of His faithfulness and love for us by the gift of His Son for our salvation from sin and His defeat of Satan once and for all.

  6. daisymarygoldr says:

    It is sad but true that without Christ there is no hope either in LIFE or in DEATH(Eph 2:12). The Bible is very clear when it says that it is appointed for us once to die, but after this the judgment…so there is no more opportunity beyond the grave. This is why the gospel urges people to not harden their hearts or procrastinate the day of their salvation. Jesus Himself did not mince words while stating “if you do not believe that I am the one I claim to be, you will indeed die in your sins,” (John 8:24).

    IMHO, whenever Jesus wept or mourned it was not about death or the pain it caused… because He is Life and Resurrection. It is actually the hard-heartedness and unbelief of people that refused to recognize but rejected ‘Life’, that caused Him to weep.

    Wisdom lies in accepting the truth for what it really stands for…because it is the truth that sets us free. The more we speculate and beat around the bush, the more we’ll remain “troubled or traumatized” and spend our lives in misery. Nothing should separate a Christian from the love of Christ which should exceed the love for everyone else. It sounds very callous but that is how it is going to be when we get to heaven. We will surely be happy to see our loved ones but nothing will match the sheer ecstasy of being forever in the presence of the ONE who gave ‘His life and all’ to get us into Heaven!

    We do grieve over losing an unsaved family member for as long as we live on this earth but we also have God’s promise (in addition to Rev 7:17) that this will not be forever… “Behold, I will create new heavens and a new earth. The former things will not be remembered, nor will they come to mind” (Isa 65:17). This is the only hope that comforts me whenever I remember my grandfather who died without knowing Christ…

  7. Becky M says:

    My niece has just recently mentioned that she hopes that someone she knows and loves meets her in heaven when she dies. One person in particular she wants to meet her is her grandmother(my mother). She has said that she worries and hopes that those she loves will meet her in heaven. When she asks me right out it’s hard for me to answer her without asking her if she trusts Jesus with everything in her life instead of asking people(like she’s taking a poll). I’ve over heard her asking other’s who they wish would meet them in heaven and she proceeds to tell them of her worries also. I know she will bring it up again to me and when she does I think I’ll mention that if Jesus meets her it would be more loving than any loved one we want to see. And if she says she hopes it will be her grandmom I think that I will say that Jesus loves her grandmom more than we do and that alone should ease her hope to meet her or any other person she loves meeting her in heaven. But, I’ve been thinking about this on my own instead of bringing it up in prayer. So, I think I’ve answered my own question on how I’m going to answer my niece when she brings it up again—I’m going to bring it up in prayer. That is what I’m hoping my niece will do also. And I hope she receives an answer to give her peace.

  8. desert rose says:

    When my Mom died, I asked a family member where Mom was? She replied, “Wherever your Mom spends eternity has been settled between her and God. For you, you also have a choice. If your Mom could talk to you right now she would tell you to trust Christ and devote your life to his service.”

  9. Gale L. Jarvis says:

    Good Evening everyone, Mart, I have been helping the Men and Women of Action the last few days get a church that was flooded last month back in shape, have not been able to read your thoughts on the blog.
    This thought of hadleing a loved one that may have left this life without the Holy Spirit to escort them into God’s presence is a hard thought to deal with but a thought the Holy Spirit has helped me with is found in Mathew 7;23, 23Then I will tell them plainly, ‘I never knew you. Away from me, you evildoers!’
    This sounds hard, but i believe the Holy Spirit has shown me those that will not be with us in heaven, it will be as if we never knew them, as daisymarygoldr said there will be no rememberance of those that will not be with us.
    Our life with God will be a life of enjoyment, nothing will be there that will cause us heartaches, or remembrance of hard times in this life.

  10. shirldavenport says:

    I’ve always been too shy to comment. But, I have to respond this time.

    I called my best friend about this a couple of weeks ago. Although we tried to reason this out, we couldn’t.

    I was so worried about my friends or family members that I knew hadn’t truly accepted Christ that I called my father. He’s a baptist minister and I try to figure things out first, then call him.

    He kind of laughed a little and told me two things.

    1) We have to remember God is all-knowing. He knew each and every one of us when He breathed life into Adam. So, when Jesus died on the cross, God already knew which of us would believe that Jesus, the son of God, died for our sins so that we may find salvation and have eternal life. None of us are a surprise to God. Just like none of those who do not believe are a surprise to God.

    Yes, we have a choice to make. But, He already knows what we are going to choose.

    2) “So the last will be first, and the first last. For many are called, but few chosen.” Matthew 20:16

    Yes, we should pray for those that we fear might not be saved. But, instead of worrying about them, we should work hard to witness to those in our lives that have been called, but who, to our knowledge, haven’t made the choice.

    Remember how you felt when you answered the call? The words, “For many are called, but FEW chosen” are so very powerful and make me tear up and say, “He chose me!” Work hard to give others that same chance or experience and, after a prayer, let God worry about the loved ones that are no longer here.

    May God grant each of you peace of mind.

  11. GGEIER says:

    I can relate to and understand that concern. The Apostle Paul, speaking by the Holy Spirit, addresses the issue in the book of Romans.

    Romans 10:5-10 (New International Version)

    6 But the righteousness that is by faith says: “Do not say in your heart, ‘Who will ascend into heaven?'” (that is, to bring Christ down) 7 “or ‘Who will descend into the deep?'” (that is, to bring Christ up from the dead). 8 But what does it say? “The word is near you; it is in your mouth and in your heart,” that is, the word of faith we are proclaiming: 9 That if you confess with your mouth, “Jesus is Lord,” and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved. 10 For it is with your heart that you believe and are justified, and it is with your mouth that you confess and are saved.

    Sometimes, it is alot easier to dwell on things which we have no control over, rather than be obedient to the scripture which says to take every thought captive and make it obedient to Jesus Christ.(2 COR 10:5) Based on that, I believe applying the scripture from Romans 10:5-10 will begin the transformation of the mind neccessary in order to bring the peace a person desires relative to the question.

    I was really impressed to see that you spoke about the different levels of punishment mentioned in the book of Revelation. It seems that often times it is overlooked. Of course, I am not basing my walk or hope in that but in the finished work of Christ Jesus upon the cross. My hope is like the Apostle stated when he said:Philippians 3:13-14 (New International Version)
    13 Brothers, I do not consider myself yet to have taken hold of it. But one thing I do: Forgetting what is behind and straining toward what is ahead, 14 I press on toward the goal to win the prize for which God has called me heavenward in Christ Jesus.

    May you be blessed through the comfort of the Holy Spirit and the peace of God offered through His Son.

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.